Blame it on Oliver Cromwell

NASA is keen on training its personnel.  I kept a list of all the training classes they sent me to take through the years. Single spaced, the list of just the titles of the classes takes a page and a half.  Seems like I should have learned something!   There were classes in software development and testing, classes in engineering topics such as stress corrosion prevention, classes in management and supervision.  But the best class was in Washington, DC in a conference room in one of the Capitol’s office buildings.  Legislative Operations was the name.  There were lectures and featured speakers including congressional staffers and lobbyists, political science professors, and various NASA officials.  We got to observe some committee hearings, discuss our observations, and we got to make the rounds on Capitol Hill visiting congressional offices.  All of this in the name of helping us understand how things really get done in Washington and how it affects our agency.

But the best and most memorable part of the class was a lecture by history/poli sci professor from GWU who explained to us how all this mess was really Oliver Cromwell’s fault.

I have told you before that I was forced to take a history course in college.  I picked “History of the Modern World” thinking it would be a current events class.  Turns out the ‘modern world’ in the classification of professional historians is anything that happened from the Renaissance to well, maybe a hundred years ago.  But we didn’t even make it to the American Civil War, too recent! We studied the English Civil War – something I had no idea existed.  In case you missed the class, there was war between the English factions who wanted either more power for the Parliament (by extension, the common people) and those who wanted more power for the King (and the nobility).  Over a decade of fighting between the Roundheads and Cavaliers (you can look it up) resulted in the triumph of the New Model Army, the Puritans, andthe Parliamentarian faction.  The King lost his head over that one.  When we later studied the French Revolution, some of the similarities were striking.  Professional historians will critique my two sentence summary of a pivotal period in English history, but that is the gist of what I remember.

This turbulent period ended with a fellow named Oliver Cromwell being proclaimed the “Lord Protector” – which is another way of saying he became absolute dictator.  Times were grim with the Puritan Major Generals enforcing all kinds of social restrictions on the people.  After about a decade, Oliver Cromwell died, and quietly the people threw off the Puritan restrictions and invited the King in exile back.

All this happened in the second half of the 1600’s.  Just about a hundred years later a group of Englishmen who colonized British North America tried to write a constitution that would organize a new government.  The example of what happened a century earlier was recent memory for them.  Firmest of the principles for the new government was that there should be no Oliver Cromwells.  No one should be able to exercise absolute power in the new government.  Instead there would be a system of checks and balances on power, and an ingenious way of guaranteeing that nothing would get done unless there was compromise between the factions.  No simple majority could ride roughshod over a numerically inferior group.  Consensus, compromise, and limits were to be the hallmark of the new government.

So when we complain about nothing getting done in Washington, the professor concluded, we should all blame Oliver Cromwell.  After all, if he had not set the example of how an absolute dictator establishes power, our forefathers might not have built a government which protects against it.  Seems they thought that efficiency in government should take back seat to more important principles. It appears they succeeded.

About waynehale

Wayne Hale is retired from NASA after 32 years. In his career he was the Space Shuttle Program Manager or Deputy for 5 years, a Space Shuttle Flight Director for 40 missions, and is currently a consultant and full time grandpa. He is available for speaking engagements through Special Aerospace Services.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Blame it on Oliver Cromwell

  1. Beth says:

    Amen! I’ve always loved History, even thought I am an engineer. We can choose to ignore it, or learn from it, but that doesn’t change the fact that it happened, and informs our future.

    The idea of three separate sources of power: Executive, Legislature, and Supreme Court, is an inspired solution to totalitarianism. There was a rather small window of opportunity for this experiment in nation building to exist; we were lucky to hit that window.

  2. Stephen Wood says:

    Hello from the UK. The Puritans also cancelled Christmas – which is the real reason that Cromwell is remembered so poorly here…

  3. Dave H. says:

    Wayne,

    In the world of safety, we review incidents, accidents, and disasters hoping that somehow the lessons will be learned. History teaches us two things; one, that all of this has happened before, and two, that unless we learn from its mistakes it will keep repeating.

    Since we’re sneaking into politics, I’ll add that, contrary to current popular opinion we don’t elect a (hopefully) benevolent dictator every four years.

  4. It’s sad to think that a person in the executive branch thinks that he can rule over the legislative and judicial branches like he does with his family businesses with an iron fist. Trump would fail if he were the CEO of a publically traded company and have to deal with the reporting that the Securities and Exchange Commission requires.

  5. Arnold says:

    Ralph, you’re looking at the wrong Dictator!
    We just got rid of one of the worst and it will take a long time to get the smell out of all Three Branches. Cromwell’s loyalists didn’t like his demise either.
    We The People have Spoken!

  6. Tom Marcucci says:

    Your posts never fail to enlighten, amuse and inform. Well done again.. and please keep them coming!

    Tom Marcucci

    ________________________________

  7. Andrew_W says:

    Sorry if I’ve fired this one at you before:

    It is the dead who govern. Look how they work their will upon us! Who have made the laws? The dead! Who have made the customs that we obey and that form and shape our lives? The dead! All the writers, when they would give weight and authority to their opinions, quote the dead. Our lives follow grooves that the dead have rub out with their thumbnails.

    M. Davisson Post (1869 – 1930)

    I think that by now we should have developed slightly more effective forms of government than those we used 300 years ago.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s